Your little is going to sleep on their bed for much of their new life. And once they exit infancy, they may use that very same mattress to sleep on in their toddler bed.
So, the best thing you can do for them is to get a right quality mattress which is going to last for many years.
But what do you look for? Do you want something soft or durable? Well, you got two options— foam and coil crib mattress. Each one has their own set of differences and characteristics which make them stand out from the other.
Let’s find it out and see which one is better.
Top 3 Best Foam Mattresses for Baby
Colgate Eco Classica III Foam Crib Mattress
One of the best and safest crib mattresses out there, the Colgate Eco Classic III is a dual-sided baby crib mattress made by an entirely different company from the one that creates the minty-fresh toothpaste.
The mattress is made from CertiPUR-US certified eco-friendly foam comprised of plant oil, so you can rest assured that it did not use any potentially harmful toxins. Moreover, its GreenGuard Gold certificate guarantees that emit very low levels of toxic chemicals.
More importantly, the mattress comes with an organic cotton cover which has a waterproof backing. This keeps the mattress so easy to clean and germ-free. Offering dual firmness, the Eco Classica III offers a firmer side for newborns to sleep on as well as a super-comfortable, less firm side for toddlers.
- Fits perfectly in standard size cribs
- Lightweight for easy and quick sheet changes
- Waterproof and organic cover
- Dual firmness
- CertiPUR-US and GreenGuard certified
- Some users claim that the edges can become prematurely frayed
My First Mattress Memory Foam Crib Mattress
Want a memory foam for your baby’s crib? Then the My First Mattress is a great buy! Purely made of the natural memory foam layer, this mattress comes with a very supportive base layer and fits snugly into standard cribs without any gaps.
CertiPUR-US certified, it features flexible polyurethane foam without any toxic chemicals that may cause health issues for your little one. It is free of phthalates and lead, mite-proof, anti-microbial and hypoallergenic. Premium memory foam adapts the shape and weight of your baby for more tailored support.
The mattress comes with an uber-soft and comfy velour outer cover that can be washed, offering great protection to the memory foam inside. Also, since the cover is waterproof, it offers easy cleaning and maintenance, keeping it sanitary and fresh with just a wipe of a damp cloth.
- Meets federal flammability standards and CPSC standards
- Washable and waterproof cover
- Adaptable memory foam
- CertiPUR-US certified
- Maybe too firm for toddlers
- Some initial off-gassing smell
Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Foam Mattress
If you are on a tight budget but want a safe mattress for your little one, then you need to consider this foam mattress from Safety 1st. The Heavenly Dreams foam mattress provides the best safety features and is highly praised by experts and users, thanks to its budget-friendly price tag.
For your convenience, the mattress comes with a vinyl cover, which you can wipe clean with ease. Made with high-density fiber thermo-bonded core, this mattress offers solid support and is equally suitable for toddlers and newborns alike.
And as its name implies, this mattress put safety first with its GreenGuard Gold certification. Plus, it also does not contain any phthalates or lead that might harm your little one.
- Sturdy and durable
- Waterproof cover
- GreenGuard Gold certified
- Seams are not as sturdy as other models
Having the most variety of all the bed types, foam mattresses can come in regular blocks of foam, organic foams memory foams, and gel foams. In general, they are the cheapest kind of mattress on the market. However, that does not mean that they do not have great qualities.
Foam mattresses are known for being affordable. You can find them anywhere from $30 – $300 for the organic types. In general, the cheaper ones are not going to hold up as well as the expensive ones that are made from denser foam. However, they are great if you need something in an instant or on a tight budget.
Foam mattresses can be organic, making it more appealing than the coil. Organic foam mattresses are much healthier for your little one since they are not made with toxic chemicals that traditional foams are made of.
In terms of comfort, foam mattresses offer you a wider range. You can get foam mattresses that are made from gel foam or memory foam. Gel foam is the best in regulating body temperatures while conforming to the body, while memory foam is best known for its contouring capabilities.
Foam mattresses are not that great with their edge supporting abilities. Although, if you want to choose foam mattresses, you need to make sure that they are not sagging at all. This is because the lack of edge support might suck your little one in the crack and cause an entrapment risk, leading to SIDS as well as the tendency of your little one falling off the bed.
However, it is good to know that not all foam mattresses lack edge support. You can find ones with reinforced edges to keep it sinking from the sides.
Over time, foam mattresses will start to break down from the core or lose its shape. This is especially bad if you want to use it for a future child since it takes away the support that a newborn needs. Foam mattresses are not a long term bed solution since they quickly breakdown.
Foam Mattresses Pros:
- More organic varieties available
- More variety for firmness
- Cost less in general
Foam Mattresses Cons:
- Can lack edge support
- Indentions are easy to make
- Less durable
Top 3 Best Coil Crib Mattresses for Babies
Simmons Kids Beautyrest Beginnings Innerspring Crib Mattress
Built with 231 luxury pocketed coil springs, the Beautyrest Beginnings Crib Mattress offers the best support for your little one. Featuring Inno foam corner protectors together with reinforced border protection, the mattress comes with extra stability to make sure that your baby is very comfortable. The reinforced corners and borders also help the mattress keep its shape and stand the test of time.
A great choice for safe sleeping, this mattress is hugged by a cotton fire-protection wrap, which is free of all toxic chemicals. Its stain-resistant cover also features a medical-grade waterproof barrier for easy cleaning. With a dual-purpose design, this mattress offers optimal firmness for both toddlers and newborns.
- Durable and stable
- Fire protection wrap
- Dual-purpose design
- Waterproof cover
- Excellent support
- Higher price tag
L.A. Baby Natural Slumber Organic Baby Crib
Featuring natural coconut fiber wrapping around heavy-duty 260 counts of 15.5 gauge steel coil, this mattress from L.A. Baby offers maximum support and stability for your little one. Also, its 9 gauge border rods offer extra support and strength to the sides.
Its organic cotton layer comes with USDA certification offering safety and utmost comfort for your little one’s good night’s sleep. And if that is not enough, it also comes with an additional blended cotton layer to add more comfort. The appealing Jacquard fabric is not only luxurious-looking but is also practical since it is hypoallergenic and comes with waterproof backing and dust mite barrier.
- Dust-mite barrier
- Maximum support and stability
- USDA certified organic cotton layer
- Super durable
- Not fully organic
My Green Mattress Emily Crib Mattress
Made from GOTS-certified organic wool and cotton, the Emily Mattress ensures that it contains no harmful elements that may take a toll on your little one’s health. Its core comes with 150 firm spring coils that offer enough firmness and stability.
Along with the 150 spring of tight coils, the manufacturer also offers a 10-year-long warranty to ensure the mattress’ durability. And unlike your average innerspring mattress, this one does not retain heat, because of its super-soft wool, giving your baby the comfort and safety they need.
With a dual functioning design, this mattress can be enjoyed by your newborn until toddler age, thanks to the different surface and level of support. In terms of certification, the mattress boasts the GreenGuard Gold certification as well as exceeding the US flammability standards.
- GOTS-certified organic cotton
- GreenGuard certified
- Exceeded US flammability standards
- Includes 150 durable innerspring coil
- No heat retention
- Dual side design
- Lengthy warranty
- Some users said that it is too small for the standard crib size
- Can sag without enough base support
Popularly known as innerspring, coil mattresses are the more durable choice. And although they may cost more and a bit heavier than foam, they do last longer and are the best option for a long-term solution.
Compared to foam mattresses, coil mattresses do cost a bit more because of what they are composed of. These mattresses are not just a couple of foam slabs pieced together— they are comfort foams, coils, casings, and more! A good coil crib mattress will be going to cost you a few hundred dollars, but you will be getting the most of your investment.
You will not be able to find a coil crib mattress that is completely organic since it is hard to create one. However, they do have some parts made of organic materials.
In general, coil mattresses are not created to be as soft as foam mattresses. However, since support is a more important aspect to your baby, innerspring has the upper hand. Coil mattresses are much more supportive since the coils work to evenly distribute the weight of your little one and contouring their body to support good spinal alignment.
Also, the inside of these mattresses comes with comfort layers that offer enough cushion, taking away any feeling of annoying springs there may be.
Because edge support is crucial for both newborns and toddlers, this is where coil mattresses trump foam ones. Coil mattresses typically have the coil lined edge that provides the support it needs. It also adds durability, preventing the mattress from sagging. With coil mattresses, you won’t usually need to use a bed rail.
Innerspring mattresses are much more durable than a foam mattress. Because springs are made from thick steel, the coils can handle the weight of your little one than most foams can. Also, you will not find them sinking in like the foam mattresses.
And because they are so durable, coil mattresses can be used for many years to come and make a great hand-me-down bed for future kids.
Coil Mattresses Pros:
- Excellent edge support
- More durable
- Better support
- Longer lasting
Coil Mattresses Cons:
- Much heavier
- Not completely eco-friendly
- Less comfort variety
As you can see, there are benefits and weaknesses in both types of mattresses. The one you choose is based on your needs. If you need something for the long-term, then the coil crib mattress is your best bet. If comfort is what you are looking for, then foam crib mattresses are good with that.
Regardless of what you choose— foam crib mattress or coil crib mattress— the right mattress will ensure that your little one is comfortable with the right support and stability for a good night’s sleep as well as being safe from dangerous toxins and chemicals.